Ask Aaron: Gay Judo Problem Page
'Should My Judo Belt and Jacket Stay in Place?'

I'm still sorta new to the game of judo and its protocol, so this may sound like a totally dumb-ass question to ask...

Should my judo belt and jacket stay in place the whole time during practice? Does it really matter
, or is it seen as disrespectful to the dojo and your partner/opponent?

There's one guy in my club who just always seems to have his belt fall off, and then he flops around in his exposed jacket, displaying his yummy tummy and chest. It's hard enough to stay focused, but when I see this
well, I imagine that you can probably get the picture pretty clearly... Keep up the great workI love this site!



Aaron's Answer to Your Problem: A Loose Judogi Is a No-No at Competition, But AOK for Daily Training

What a nice, easy question for me to respond to this time aroundno tears, no tantrums, no twisted tales of unrequited love. But let's get real here, mate: This isn't a problem, it's a perk!

The International Judo Federation states that it is an offense for any judoka 'to intentionally disarrange his own judogi or to untie or retie the belt or the trousers without the referee's permission'. Ignoring this directive will result in the awarding of a shido penalty against you, thereby upping your opponent's score by three points. Why? Because it's deemed a signifier of 'negative judo' i.e. an attempt on your part to interrupt the match or otherwise hinder play.

A prime example of this behavior occurred during the 1999 Pan-American Championships final between the United States' Hiriam Cruz and the Dominican Republic's Juan Bautista.

'This was by no means a classic final,' writes IJF chronicler Barnaby Chesterman, 'as Bautista infuriated the crowd with constant stalling tactics and the referee struggled to give the right scores. Both fighters were penalized shido early on and then Bautista took the lead with yuko from kata-guruma. Cruz hit back scoring koka with o-goshi but he conceded another penalty as Bautista resorted to time wasting tactics to break up the fight. It was unnecessary from Bautista who looked a good fighter, but he turned the crowd against him as he strolled around the mat after matte was called and took long periods of time to tie his belt, which he did loosely so that it kept coming undone again giving him more excuses to rest. Cruz allowed himself to get frustrated and was again thrown for yuko as Bautista held on for victory...'

Somessing around with your gi during competitive play is definitely considered a no-no (although it's worth paying attention to the fact that, in Bautista's case at least, it proved a very successful ploy for establishing both psychological and physical dominance over his opponent).

Of course, judogis come loose all the time, especially during intense combat; no penalty can be given for this natural phenomenonunless you start to rearrange your uniform without the referee's permission, in which case you're back to 'negative judo' and that undesirable shido score. But what impact does all this have when you're practicing at your local club, without a nit-picking referee to get in the way of your grappling?

The answer is zero: You can do pretty much whatever you want, meaning that if you've got this guy, and he likes to spar without a belt, revealing a hard stomach, big pecs, and stiff nipples for your delight and delectation, then... go right ahead and follow suit! When it's your turn to partner him, let your obi slip off and prepare yourself for some mindblowing skin-on-skin, belly-to-belly action. Make sure you're wearing something with plenty of support beneath your gi pants, thoughunless you want him to see just how much you appreciate his beltless bod!



Web Links:

International Judo Federation

The Official IJF Rules of Judo

Back to Ask Judo Problem Archive

Author Info:

Contact Aaron

Read Aaron's Biography